My First Miso Soup
Bonito flakes were also new to me. Apparently they are made by smoking and drying out skipjack tuna, pressing it into a block, and then shaving flakes off into bags. I cautiously opened the bag and took a whiff, expecting to be bowled over by a nasty fish odor. To my utter surprise the smell made my mouth water. It had a sweetly smoky fish aroma that was quite pleasant and made me think of an umami flavor.
Making the ichiban-dashi was rather like a dance of ingredients in sequences that were new to me. You bring part of the water and the konbu to a boil, then remove the konbu and add more water. When that boils you turn it off and add the bonito flakes and wait while they fall to the bottom of the pot. Then you strain out the bonito flakes and set aside the water for some other use.Next with the leftover bonito flakes and konbu, you make the niban-dashi (second stock). Adding water and the leftover bonito and konbu to a pot you simmer it for a while and then add in more bonito flakes, again waiting until they float to the bottom. Then you strain everything saving the water and discarding the rest. When this is all finished you have your stock and can finally get around to making the miso soup. Yes, it is a lot of steps but I think the purpose is to achieve the correct level of flavor in the stock, one which will not overwhelm a delicate miso but still have complexity from the konbu and bonito flakes.
So how did it taste after dancing around with unfamiliar ingredients all afternoon? Well, I’m going to be honest. It was just okay. I learned that there are several different types of miso which vary on the flavor spectrum from sweet to savory. This recipe used a lot of Shiro miso, which is a sweet blond colored miso. It created a cloying almost muddy flavor and I think I prefer a more savory style Hacho miso. Also, in my efforts to make this soup more of a “meal” than an appetizer I ignored the recommended proportions of tofu and dumped in the whole package. This resulted in a miso-tofu stew. Not quite the delicate soup I was aiming for.
Will we try this again? Absolutely! Now that the ingredients and processes are demystified, I am eager to give this a try again with different miso. The broth was very satisfying and I think by tweaking the ingredients to match our preferences I will be able to make a miso soup that we enjoy on a regular basis.
The step-by-step process and recipe from The Paupered Chef can be found here.





TKW said..
I am so impressed! I never knew miso soup was so complicated! I think I’d like the more savory version better, too. But tofu is, um, icky…do I sound like a 5 year old or what?
Gorgeous pics.
May 20, 2009 @ 8:21 am
nithya at hungrydesi said..
Wow, looks great! I’m also impressed…I buy the paste from Whole Foods
May 20, 2009 @ 8:34 am
Sarah, The New Girl said..
those ingredients are definitely a mystery to me
but looks like an adventure! glad you liked it!
May 20, 2009 @ 8:51 am
kissmyspatul.com said..
wow! i can NOT wait to make this! i love miso soup and my fist attempt was quite a disaster, so i’m excited to try your version. it looks fabulous.
May 20, 2009 @ 10:04 am
Kate said..
My daughter has a book called “My First Book of Sushi” that has a line “Miso in my sippy cup, tofu in my bowl.” Your post totally reminded me of this!
I think you can buy instant dashi if you wanted to streamline the process. This does look much better than the Kikkoman packets I’m used to!
May 20, 2009 @ 11:43 am
Screwed Up Texan said..
I first tried Miso soup when I lived in Indiana with a family of Japanese heritage. It was one of my favorite soups and I still eat it from time to time. Glad you discovered how to make it from scratch, because I always made the instant stuff from a package.
May 20, 2009 @ 2:23 pm
Charles G Thompson said..
This looks so yummy-comforting – the way I usually feel when I eat miso soup. Very nice post, and great pics. It was great meeting and chatting with you at the IFBC over the weekend.
May 20, 2009 @ 5:26 pm
Phoo-D said..
TKW- You could definitely skip the tofu.
Nithya- Sounds like an easy way to go. Thanks for stopping by!
Kissmyspatula- Love your blog name. Thanks for stopping by.
Kate- What a great book! I will have to look for that one.
SUT- It really is a lovely comfort food.
Charles- It was great to meet you too. Thanks for stopping by!
May 21, 2009 @ 9:31 am
Marta said..
Miso soup just has a way of warming me up from the inside and comforting me liek no other soup! I don’t know what it is, I don’t even like brothy soups that much! This looks great, I like the bonito flakes in it, must add a nice salty touch!
May 21, 2009 @ 2:00 pm
Kristin @ Going Country said..
This has nothing to do with miso soup, I just wanted to tell you that I LOVE the stylization of the “P” in your banner, with the asparagus. That’s cool, yo.
May 22, 2009 @ 6:15 am
Phoo-D said..
Marta- The bonito flakes defintely add a great flavor. Thanks for stopping by!
Kristin- Awww, thanks! It took me a while to figure it out in Photoshop, but I like the end result too,
May 22, 2009 @ 9:50 am